5 Strategies for Handling Difficult Coworkers and Improving Workplace Dynamics

5 Strategies for Handling Difficult Coworkers and Improving Workplace Dynamics

In today’s diverse and dynamic workplaces, it’s common to encounter various types of difficult coworkers who can significantly influence the overall work environment. These challenging colleagues may exhibit behaviors such as negativity, excessive criticism, lack of teamwork, or communication difficulties, all of which can create tension and hinder productivity within teams. Understanding and effectively managing these workplace dynamics is essential for fostering a positive and collaborative atmosphere where employees can thrive. This guide will delve into strategies and approaches for dealing with difficult coworkers, helping individuals navigate challenging situations with professionalism and resilience.

Your AI-powered meeting assistant — Huddles

Smarter agenda , valuable conclusions

Leading by Positive Example

Setting a constructive tone in the workplace begins with leaders and colleagues who exhibit behaviors and attitudes that promote a healthy and productive work environment. Here are some strategies for fostering a positive atmosphere:

  1. Maintain a Positive Attitude: Approach challenges with optimism and focus on solutions rather than dwelling on problems. Positivity is contagious and can inspire others to adopt a similar mindset.
  2. Practice Active Listening: Show genuine interest in what others have to say, and validate their perspectives. This encourages open communication and demonstrates respect for colleagues’ ideas.
  3. Promote Inclusivity: Create an inclusive environment where everyone feels valued and heard. Encourage diverse perspectives and actively work to eliminate discrimination and bias.
  4. Demonstrate Empathy: Understand and acknowledge the emotions and experiences of your coworkers. Empathetic leaders can build stronger connections and foster a sense of belonging among team members.
  5. Encourage Collaboration: Emphasize teamwork and cooperation. Foster a culture where employees support each other, share knowledge, and collaborate on projects.
  6. Set Clear Expectations: Ensure that expectations regarding work quality, deadlines, and behavior are clearly communicated. This helps prevent misunderstandings and conflicts.

Leading by example not only promotes a positive workplace culture but also influences team behavior. When colleagues observe leaders consistently displaying these positive traits and behaviors, they are more likely to emulate them, creating a ripple effect throughout the organization. By setting a constructive tone and modeling desired behaviors, leaders can contribute to a more harmonious and productive work environment.

Understanding Underlying Issues

Recognizing and empathizing with the personal struggles of coworkers is a crucial aspect of dealing with difficult colleagues in a compassionate and effective manner. Here are some key considerations:

  1. Empathetic Recognition: Difficult coworkers may be going through personal challenges or facing professional stressors that affect their behavior. Taking the time to acknowledge their difficulties without judgment can help create a more empathetic workplace.
  2. Active Listening: When a colleague is experiencing challenges, it’s essential to lend a listening ear. Allow them to express their concerns and feelings, and demonstrate genuine interest in understanding their perspective.
  3. Avoid Making Assumptions: Avoid jumping to conclusions about the motivations behind a coworker’s behavior. Instead, ask open-ended questions to gain a clearer understanding of their point of view.
  4. Offer Support: If appropriate, offer your support or assistance to colleagues who are facing difficulties. This could be in the form of helping with workload, offering resources, or simply being there to listen.
  5. Maintain Discretion: When approaching sensitive situations, it’s important to maintain discretion and confidentiality. Ensure that any conversations or support offered are kept private unless the coworker gives explicit permission to share.
  6. Respect Boundaries: While offering support is important, it’s also essential to respect the boundaries and preferences of your coworkers. Some individuals may prefer to handle their challenges independently, while others may welcome assistance.

By recognizing and empathizing with the underlying issues that may be affecting a difficult coworker’s behavior, you can approach the situation with greater understanding and compassion. This can lead to more productive conversations and potentially help your coworker navigate their challenges more effectively.

Adopting a Solution-Focused Mindset

In dealing with difficult coworkers, adopting a solution-focused mindset can be highly effective in resolving conflicts and improving workplace dynamics. Here’s a deeper look at how to embrace this approach:

  1. Shift from Problems to Solutions: One of the fundamental principles of a solution-focused mindset is to shift the focus from dwelling on problems to actively seeking solutions. Instead of getting bogged down by the negative aspects of a situation, concentrate on what can be done to address it positively.
  2. Collaborative Problem-Solving: Encourage collaborative problem-solving techniques that involve both you and your difficult coworker working together to find solutions. This approach promotes a sense of ownership and shared responsibility for resolving issues.
  3. Identify Common Goals: Find common ground with your coworker by identifying shared goals or objectives. This can create a sense of alignment and purpose, making it easier to work together toward a solution.
  4. Focus on the Future: Solution-focused thinking emphasizes looking forward rather than dwelling on past conflicts. Ask questions that help envision a future where the problem is resolved, and actions are taken to achieve that outcome.
  5. Use Strengths-Based Approach: Recognize and leverage each other’s strengths and capabilities in problem-solving. Acknowledge what you and your coworker bring to the table to overcome challenges more effectively.
  6. Small Steps Toward Progress: Break down complex issues into smaller, manageable steps. This approach makes problem-solving more achievable and less overwhelming, leading to incremental progress.
  7. Positive Language and Framing: Use positive language when discussing challenges and solutions. Framing discussions in a positive and constructive manner can foster a more conducive environment for finding resolutions.
  8. Feedback and Flexibility: Be open to giving and receiving constructive feedback. A solution-focused approach involves flexibility and adaptability to adjust strategies as needed to achieve the desired outcomes.
  9. Celebrate Successes: When progress is made or solutions are found, take the time to acknowledge and celebrate these successes. Positive reinforcement can motivate continued cooperation and problem-solving efforts.

By adopting a solution-focused mindset, you can create a more positive and proactive approach to dealing with difficult coworkers. This approach not only helps in resolving conflicts but also contributes to a more collaborative and harmonious work environment.

Goal Alignment to Minimize Conflicts

One effective strategy for dealing with difficult coworkers is to emphasize goal alignment within the team. This approach can help bridge personality differences, reduce conflicts, and foster a more collaborative work environment. Here’s a closer look at how goal alignment works:

  1. Setting Shared Objectives: Encourage your team to establish shared objectives that everyone can rally around. When team members have common goals, it provides a unifying purpose that can help mitigate conflicts arising from personality clashes. Shared objectives create a sense of cohesion and teamwork.
  2. Focus on Collective Success: Emphasize that the success of the team as a whole is more important than individual achievements. When team members understand that their efforts contribute to a larger, collective goal, they are more likely to set aside personal differences for the greater good.
  3. Clarifying Roles and Responsibilities: Ensure that each team member has a clear understanding of their role and responsibilities within the context of the shared goals. This clarity can prevent misunderstandings and conflicts related to overlapping duties or unmet expectations.
  4. Regular Communication: Foster open and transparent communication within the team. Encourage team members to discuss progress, challenges, and potential roadblocks related to achieving shared objectives. Regular check-ins and updates can help keep everyone on the same page.
  5. Problem-Solving Orientation: Cultivate a problem-solving orientation within the team. When conflicts arise, frame them as obstacles that the team needs to overcome together to achieve its goals. This approach shifts the focus from blame to finding solutions.
  6. Conflict Resolution Mechanisms: Establish clear and fair conflict resolution mechanisms within the team. Encourage team members to address conflicts constructively and provide support, such as mediation or team discussions, when needed.
  7. Celebrate Achievements: Recognize and celebrate milestones and achievements related to shared goals. Acknowledging and rewarding progress can boost team morale and motivate continued collaboration.
  8. Feedback and Evaluation: Regularly gather feedback from team members about their experiences working toward shared objectives. Use this feedback to make improvements in team dynamics and goal alignment.
  9. Leadership Support: Ensure that team leaders and managers actively support and reinforce the importance of goal alignment. Leaders should lead by example, demonstrating their commitment to the team’s shared objectives.

The role of clear goals in team cohesion cannot be overstated. When team members understand their common purpose and are committed to achieving shared objectives, it can create a sense of unity that transcends individual differences. By promoting goal alignment, teams can minimize conflicts stemming from personality clashes and work together more harmoniously toward their common goals.

Addressing Issues with Management

Dealing with difficult coworkers may sometimes require intervention from management or supervisors. Knowing when and how to escalate concerns to higher-ups is essential for maintaining a productive and harmonious work environment. Here’s a closer look at this aspect:

  1. Recognize the Need for Escalation: Before approaching management, carefully assess the situation to determine if it warrants escalation. Consider factors such as the severity of the issue, its impact on your work and the team, and whether attempts to resolve it at the team level have been unsuccessful. Escalation should be reserved for significant and persistent problems that hinder team performance or create a hostile work environment.
  2. Document the Issue: Before discussing the issue with management, gather evidence and document relevant incidents. This documentation should include dates, times, locations, descriptions of behavior, and any communication related to the problem. Having a well-documented record can strengthen your case and provide context when speaking to management.
  3. Choose the Right Time and Place: When you decide to escalate a concern, choose an appropriate time and setting for the discussion. Request a private meeting with your supervisor or manager, preferably in a quiet and confidential space where you can speak openly.
  4. Prepare Your Talking Points: Before the meeting, prepare a concise and organized summary of the issue. Be specific about the problem, its impact, and any actions you’ve taken to address it at the team level. Highlight the potential consequences for the team’s productivity or well-being.
  5. Be Professional and Constructive: During the discussion with management, maintain a professional and constructive tone. Avoid making personal attacks or using emotional language. Instead, focus on the facts, the impact on work, and potential solutions. Express your willingness to work collaboratively to find a resolution.
  6. Listen to Management’s Perspective: Be open to feedback and suggestions from management. They may have insights or information that you are not aware of. Engage in a two-way conversation aimed at finding a mutually beneficial solution.
  7. Propose Solutions: When discussing the issue with management, come prepared with potential solutions or ideas for addressing the problem. Demonstrating your commitment to finding a resolution can be viewed positively by supervisors.
  8. Follow Up: After the meeting, follow up with management to ensure that any agreed-upon actions are being taken. Maintain open communication and keep management informed of any developments or changes in the situation.
  9. Seek HR Guidance: If the issue remains unresolved or escalates further, consider reaching out to your organization’s Human Resources department. HR professionals can provide guidance, mediation, and additional support in addressing workplace conflicts.
  10. Remain Professional: Throughout the process, maintain professionalism and focus on your job responsibilities. Avoid discussing the issue with colleagues unless necessary, as gossip and speculation can exacerbate the situation.

Remember that addressing issues with management should be a last resort, and it’s preferable to attempt resolution at the team level first. However, when conflicts persist and significantly impact your work or well-being, involving management may be necessary to find a constructive solution and maintain a positive work environment.

Finding Common Ground in Disagreements

In the workplace, conflicts and disagreements are inevitable, but they can be effectively managed and resolved by focusing on shared interests and striving for mutual understanding. Here’s a closer look at techniques for finding common ground in disagreements:

  1. Active Listening: To understand the perspectives of others, practice active listening. Give your full attention when someone is speaking, ask clarifying questions, and avoid interrupting. This demonstrates respect and a genuine interest in understanding their point of view.
  2. Empathize: Put yourself in the other person’s shoes and try to understand their feelings and motivations. Empathy can create a sense of connection and make it easier to find common ground.
  3. Identify Shared Goals: In many cases, conflicting parties share common overarching goals, even if they have different ideas about how to achieve them. Identify these shared objectives and use them as a basis for finding agreement.
  4. Separate Issues from Personalities: Focus on the specific issues or disagreements at hand rather than on personal attributes or characteristics. Avoid making personal attacks or judgments, as this can escalate conflicts.
  5. Explore Different Perspectives: Encourage open and honest communication about the reasons behind each person’s position. Understanding the underlying reasons can lead to common ground.
  6. Brainstorm Solutions: Engage in brainstorming sessions to generate a variety of potential solutions to the problem. Encourage all parties to contribute ideas without criticism at this stage. The goal is to explore multiple options.
  7. Prioritize Interests: After brainstorming, prioritize the interests or needs that are most important to each party. This can help identify areas of agreement and disagreement.
  8. Trade-offs and Compromises: In some cases, finding common ground may involve trade-offs or compromises. Be open to negotiation and be willing to give up something less important to you in exchange for achieving a shared goal.
  9. Seek Mediation: If disagreements persist, consider involving a neutral third party, such as a mediator or a supervisor, to help facilitate the conversation and find common ground. Mediators can guide the discussion and offer objective insights.
  10. Use “I” Statements: When expressing your perspective or needs, use “I” statements to convey your feelings and thoughts without blaming or accusing others. For example, say, “I feel concerned when…” rather than “You always…”
  11. Maintain Respectful Communication: Throughout the process, maintain respectful and professional communication. Avoid hostility, sarcasm, or dismissive language, as these can hinder progress.
  12. Agree to Disagree: In some cases, it may not be possible to reach a full agreement. In such situations, it’s acceptable to agree to disagree on certain points while still finding ways to work together constructively.
  13. Follow-Up and Review: After reaching an agreement or compromise, follow up to ensure that all parties are adhering to the agreed-upon terms. Regularly review progress and make adjustments as necessary.

Finding common ground in disagreements requires patience, active listening, and a willingness to collaborate. By focusing on shared interests and working toward mutual understanding, conflicts can often be resolved in a way that benefits all parties involved and promotes a healthier work environment.

Reducing Negative Interactions

Dealing with difficult coworkers can be challenging, but it’s essential to maintain a professional and productive work environment. Here are strategies for reducing negative interactions and fostering a more positive atmosphere:

  1. Set Boundaries: Establish clear boundaries in your interactions with difficult colleagues. Be polite and professional but firm about what behavior is acceptable. For example, if someone is prone to gossip, politely decline to engage in such conversations.
  2. Limit Contact: When possible, minimize your exposure to difficult individuals. This doesn’t mean avoiding them entirely but rather prioritizing tasks and responsibilities that don’t require extensive collaboration.
  3. Choose Your Battles: Not every disagreement or conflict needs to be addressed immediately. Assess the situation and determine whether it’s worth engaging in a potentially negative interaction. Sometimes, it’s better to let minor issues go.
  4. Maintain Emotional Control: Difficult coworkers may try to provoke emotional reactions. Practice emotional intelligence and self-control. Stay composed and avoid reacting impulsively to provocation.
  5. Document Interactions: Keep a record of problematic interactions, including dates, times, and details. This documentation can be valuable if you need to escalate the issue to management or HR.
  6. Seek Support: Talk to colleagues or supervisors you trust about your experiences. They may offer guidance, insights, or even mediate conflicts when necessary.
  7. Escalate When Appropriate: If a coworker’s behavior becomes disruptive, harmful, or repeatedly crosses professional boundaries, consider escalating the issue to your supervisor or HR department. Be prepared to provide evidence and specific examples.
  8. Use Positive Reinforcement: Encourage positive behavior in difficult coworkers by acknowledging and appreciating their efforts when they exhibit desirable qualities. Positive reinforcement can help reinforce better interactions.
  9. Maintain Professionalism: No matter how challenging a colleague may be, always uphold professionalism. Respond to negative behavior with respect and maturity, even when others don’t.
  10. Seek Resolution: If there’s a specific issue causing conflict, try to address it directly with the difficult coworker in a calm and non-confrontational manner. Use “I” statements to express your concerns and discuss potential solutions.
  11. Engage in Conflict Resolution Training: Some organizations offer conflict resolution training to help employees manage and resolve interpersonal conflicts effectively. Consider taking advantage of such resources if available.
  12. Focus on Your Well-being: Prioritize self-care and well-being. Engage in stress-reduction activities, maintain work-life balance, and seek support from friends, family, or mental health professionals if needed.
  13. Evaluate Your Options: If negative interactions persist and significantly impact your well-being and job satisfaction, assess whether it’s time to explore alternative job opportunities within or outside the organization.

Professionalism in the Face of Adversity

Maintaining professionalism in challenging situations with difficult coworkers is essential for preserving a harmonious work environment and your own credibility. Here’s how to exhibit professionalism when faced with adversity:

  1. Stay Calm: When confronted with negativity or conflict, prioritize staying calm. Take a deep breath and collect your thoughts before responding. Reacting impulsively can escalate the situation.
  2. Active Listening: Practice active listening by giving your coworker your full attention when they express concerns or frustrations. Show empathy by nodding, maintaining eye contact, and using verbal cues like “I understand” or “Tell me more.”
  3. Empathize: Try to understand your coworker’s perspective, even if you disagree. Empathy can defuse tension and demonstrate your willingness to find common ground.
  4. Use “I” Statements: When addressing issues, use “I” statements to express your feelings and concerns without blaming or accusing. For example, say, “I feel frustrated when there are last-minute changes to our projects” instead of “You always make last-minute changes.”
  5. Maintain Respect: Treat your coworker with respect, even if you find their behavior challenging. Avoid personal attacks, derogatory comments, or any form of disrespectful communication.
  6. Stay Solution-Focused: Redirect the conversation towards finding solutions to the issue at hand. Instead of dwelling on the problem, ask questions like, “What can we do to resolve this matter?” or “How can we prevent similar issues in the future?”
  7. Use Assertive Communication: Assertiveness is a balanced communication style that expresses your needs and boundaries while respecting those of others. Practice assertive communication by being direct, honest, and respectful in your interactions.
  8. Set Clear Boundaries: If a coworker consistently crosses boundaries, politely but firmly communicate your limits. For example, say, “I prefer to keep our discussions focused on work-related topics” if someone engages in personal conversations during work hours.
  9. Avoid Gossip: Gossiping about difficult coworkers can create a toxic work environment. Refrain from discussing conflicts or issues with other colleagues unless it’s necessary for conflict resolution.
  10. Seek Guidance: If you’re unsure about how to handle a difficult situation professionally, seek guidance from your supervisor, HR department, or a mentor. They can provide valuable insights and support.
  11. Disengage When Necessary: If a conversation becomes unproductive or escalates, consider disengaging temporarily. Politely express your intention to revisit the discussion when emotions have cooled off.
  12. Maintain Documentation: Keep records of relevant interactions, including emails, messages, or meeting notes. This documentation can be useful if you need to involve HR or management in resolving the issue.
  13. Reflect and Learn: After challenging interactions, take time to reflect on what you’ve learned from the experience. Consider how you can handle similar situations more effectively in the future.

Building Supportive Alliances

Cultivating positive relationships with like-minded colleagues and building a supportive network in the workplace can significantly enhance your ability to deal with difficult coworkers and navigate workplace challenges effectively. Here’s how to build and leverage supportive alliances:

  1. Identify Like-Minded Colleagues: Pay attention to coworkers who share similar values, work ethic, or professional goals. These individuals are more likely to understand your perspective and provide valuable support.
  2. Networking: Actively engage in workplace networking opportunities, such as team-building events, professional development workshops, or company gatherings. These events offer a chance to meet and connect with colleagues from various departments.
  3. Join Professional Groups: Participate in professional organizations or groups related to your field or industry. These external networks can introduce you to professionals who can offer insights and support.
  4. Mentorship: Seek out mentors or senior colleagues who can provide guidance and advice on handling workplace challenges. Mentors can share their experiences and help you navigate complex situations.
  5. Mutual Support: Offer your support to others in your network as well. Building alliances is a two-way street, and providing assistance or guidance when needed fosters a culture of reciprocity and trust.
  6. Peer Groups: Form peer support groups within your organization, where colleagues can discuss challenges, share solutions, and provide emotional support. These groups can offer a safe space to address common workplace issues.
  7. Professional Development: Collaborate with your supportive network on professional development opportunities. Attend workshops, conferences, or training sessions together to enhance your skills and knowledge.
  8. Conflict Resolution: When faced with a challenging coworker or conflict, consult your supportive alliances for advice and perspectives. They may offer valuable insights or alternative approaches to resolving the issue.
  9. Emotional Support: Lean on your network for emotional support during particularly stressful or difficult periods at work. Sharing your feelings and concerns with trusted colleagues can be cathartic and reassuring.
  10. Problem-Solving: Collaborate with your network to brainstorm solutions to workplace challenges. Different perspectives and experiences can lead to innovative problem-solving approaches.
  11. Advocacy: In situations where you need support in addressing workplace issues, your allies can advocate for you when appropriate. They can vouch for your professionalism and contribute to a positive perception of your contributions in the organization.
  12. Maintain Respect and Trust: Uphold respect and trust within your supportive alliances. These relationships thrive when there is mutual respect, trustworthiness, and a commitment to each other’s success.
  13. Professionalism: Even within a network of allies, maintain professionalism and ethical conduct. Avoid compromising your integrity or engaging in negative behaviors, as this can damage your reputation and those of your allies.
  14. Expand Your Circle: Continually seek opportunities to expand your supportive network. Be open to connecting with individuals from diverse backgrounds and roles within your organization.

The power of supportive alliances lies in the collective strength and resilience they provide. When facing challenging coworkers or navigating workplace difficulties, knowing you have a network of colleagues who understand and support you can make a significant difference in your ability to thrive and succeed in your professional journey.

Engaging in Constructive Conversations

Effectively addressing workplace issues with difficult coworkers often requires engaging in constructive conversations that are both tactful and clear. Here are some strategies and techniques for navigating these challenging discussions:

  1. Prepare and Plan: Before initiating a conversation, take time to clarify your goals and objectives. What do you hope to achieve with this conversation? Outline the key points you want to address and anticipate potential reactions or responses from the other person.
  2. Choose the Right Time and Place: Select an appropriate setting for the conversation, preferably in a private and quiet space. Timing is crucial; choose a moment when both you and the coworker are relatively relaxed and not rushed.
  3. Use “I” Statements: Frame your concerns using “I” statements to express your feelings, thoughts, and needs. For example, say, “I feel concerned when…” instead of making accusatory statements.
  4. Active Listening: Practice active listening by giving the other person your full attention. Show empathy and understanding by nodding, maintaining eye contact, and paraphrasing their statements to ensure you’ve understood correctly.
  5. Stay Calm and Composed: Maintain a composed and neutral tone during the conversation, even if the coworker becomes defensive or confrontational. Avoid raising your voice or becoming emotionally reactive.
  6. Focus on Behavior, Not Personality: Address specific behaviors or actions that are causing issues rather than making judgments about the coworker’s personality or character. This approach makes the conversation less personal and more objective.
  7. Ask Open-Ended Questions: Encourage open and honest communication by asking open-ended questions. These questions invite the coworker to share their perspective and insights, fostering a constructive dialogue.
  8. Express Empathy: Acknowledge the coworker’s perspective and feelings, even if you disagree. Expressing empathy can help de-escalate tense situations and create a more cooperative atmosphere.
  9. Avoid Blame and Accusations: Refrain from blaming or accusing the coworker. Instead, focus on problem-solving and finding mutually acceptable solutions.
  10. Use Concrete Examples: Provide specific examples of behaviors or situations that have led to concerns. Concrete examples make it easier for the coworker to understand and address the issues.
  11. Seek Agreement: Encourage the coworker to identify areas of agreement and common ground. This can help build rapport and facilitate collaboration in finding solutions.
  12. Stay Solution-Focused: Keep the conversation centered on finding solutions and improving the working relationship. Brainstorm potential solutions together and be open to compromise.
  13. Set Clear Expectations: Clearly communicate your expectations and the changes you’d like to see. Ensure that both you and the coworker have a shared understanding of what needs to happen moving forward.
  14. Follow Up: After the conversation, follow up as needed to track progress and ensure that any agreed-upon actions are being implemented. Regular communication can help prevent issues from resurfacing.
  15. Seek Mediation: If conversations with the coworker do not lead to resolution, consider involving a supervisor or HR representative as a mediator to facilitate the discussion and explore additional solutions.
  16. Document the Conversation: Keep a record of the conversation, including key points discussed, agreements reached, and any action items. This documentation can be valuable if the issue persists and further intervention is required.

Engaging in constructive conversations with difficult coworkers requires patience, empathy, and effective communication skills. By addressing concerns directly and collaboratively, you increase the likelihood of finding solutions and improving the working relationship, contributing to a healthier and more productive workplace.


Effectively managing difficult coworkers is a crucial skill for thriving in the workplace amidst various challenges. The strategies discussed throughout this guide provide a roadmap for navigating workplace dynamics with professionalism and tact. By leading by positive example, understanding underlying issues, adopting a solution-focused mindset, and seeking common ground, you can build stronger working relationships and foster a more harmonious environment. Remember that communication is key, and approaching challenging conversations with empathy and constructive intent can lead to resolutions that benefit both parties. Additionally, embracing resilience and adaptability is essential for professional growth, as learning to navigate and overcome workplace challenges ultimately strengthens your skill set and contributes to your long-term success. In challenging times, your ability to effectively manage difficult coworkers and situations can be a valuable asset in any career journey.

smart notes icon
Get Live AI Meeting Notes with Huddles

With just one click to activate AI notetaking, Huddles automatically generates live AI notes based on your transcript, just like a personal assistant. 

Table of Contents

Automate your meeting notes with Huddles

Huddles transcribes, summarizes and takes notes for you so you can focus on discussions and team collaboration.