Book free demo

AI-generated summaries

What is the reliability of AI-generated summaries

AI-generated summaries

What is the reliability of AI-generated summaries

AI has transformed information consumption by efficiently summarizing content, saving time and boosting productivity. Yet, the trustworthiness of these summaries depends on their accuracy, context retention, and conveyance of the original message’s tone and purpose.

AI Summaries – Speed and Accuracy

While being very fast at reading huge amounts of text and summarizing it in just a few seconds, the accuracy of AI depends. Sometimes, with less sophisticated AI models, this can compromise accuracy, as the information is not adequately processed. However, modern AI has no such problems as it can comfortably read text of different styles because the algorithms are trained on various books and documents . Existing data says that modern AI with a certain degree of accuracy can summarize different types of information in approximately 90% of cases, where the data is well-represented . However, for some narrowly-focused topics, where accurate information is not widespread, the extractive and abstractive approaches can have lower accuracy.

Considering the Training Data and Problem Complexity

AI models are trained on specific data and then apply abductive logic . Therefore, when training on extensive texts and big data, large models can more accurately generalize the text and understand the key nuances. These models are highly complex and can, for example, work with both scientific papers and high literature: the latter, for example, often does not contain any specific conclusions, which the model must recognize . However, the complexity of the model itself also plays a big role: it is known that models using deep learning technologies read the source text and can accurately reproduce and convey it to the user, including the information available in it.

Preservation of Context and Tone

One of the important qualities of a good summary is the preservation of the original context of what the grown text speaks about. Modern AI can accurately understand the context of certain texts, preserving not only useful information but also the original tone — if necessary, it will reproduce the humor of the source text. However, with the increasing complexity, the task of AI increases, as it is still unable to reliably recognize sarcasm or other feelings . In other words, in a situation where the tone of the original text is crucial for understanding, this can lead to erroneous summary generation. However, with further progress and the development of new technology, modern AI will be able to learn the differences better and more accurately.

Semantic Accuracy vs. Factual Accuracy

Semantic and factual accuracy are terms that must be well-understood in a world where AI produces written content. Both types of accuracy are critical to determining how well-written information is, and even though both are essential for revealing truth and knowledge, they are not inherently related, as they concern whether the information is correct or not.

AI-generated summaries

Semantic Accuracy

The term refers to proper meaning and interpretation, or simply whether the information delivered is correct. If it does, it is semantically accurate. Semantically accurate summaries of an assumed “highly technical, medical research paper” would cover it, making all necessary implications, hypotheses, and conclusions. If a computer writes such a summary, it must use semantic features such as unambiguous NLU and context detection. However, the use of these utilities is not sufficient because in many cases AI will still get the semantics wrong or miss some nuances in language, slang, idioms, and cultural explanations. The main reason why it is possible to train the system using a wider vocabulary and target as many lexical inaccuracies as possible in the linguistic datasets that cover most languages and economies is that it will attempt to access and reuse human semantics to achieve better writing results over time.

Factual Accuracy

Factual accuracy is not about context or shades, but only about the information being correct. Facts can be verified, counted, and checked, and there is nowhere for subjectivity. For example, we know where, when, due to what, and because of whom a war broke out. In order to validly summarize any information about such an event, it is necessary to adhere to officially confirmed and verifiable and proven data. An AI must verify facts and data through a search engine that translates the data into secure answers provided by the most reputable researchers and scholars. Information is verified by reference to a memorized database, which can be updated as new information becomes available. As companies update their databases regularly to ensure their data is the most up-to-date, the information AI serves is usually factual, although sometimes the pace can be frightening and can only result in unreliable results.

AI-generated summaries

In order to achieve the highest mark of factual accuracy, AI must be armed with the ability to refer to as great a number of the most current and reliable sources of facts in its analysis. In addition, AI’s links to such sources must be used in the analytic portion developed in the construction of documents. Finally, the level of artificial intelligence required to gain the highest respect of factual accuracy is challenged by the sheer amount of development in various scientific fields around the world.

Verifying AI Summary Reliability

Trustworthy AI summaries require a strong verification framework, including both automated systems and humans, to check the accuracy, context, and completeness of the generated content.

Cross-Reference with Source Material

A summary should be cross-referenced with the original source material. Tools and algorithms can be used to automatically compare the two and discover any discrepancies to point them out to a human decision-maker for verification. In practice, this means that if the AI is summarising a scientific research paper, the resulting product should clearly state what the study was about, what questions it aimed to answer, and what it ultimately found without making up any facts and figures. An automated system can easily spot such a discrepancy but will not make the final decision.

Human Expert Review

An additional level on top of automated cross-referencing, human expert review ensures that the verification process is as close to perfect as possible. An expert in a given field can determine whether a summary correctly captures the nuances and technicalities of the original piece as intended. This step is essential in many contexts where an incorrect summary may be no different from an incorrect fact – such as in legal documents or summaries of medical research.

Feedback Loops for Constant Improvement

A feedback loop that integrates user and expert information about the correctness and usefulness of a given summary is included to enable drive continuous improvement. The information obtained from real-life humans can be used to refine the implementing AI algorithms through better training data – in other words, feedback is a valuable resource for improving future summaries. The data shows that platforms that retain such options have high levels of initial AI-generated content inaccuracy, which drops over time thanks to the feedback loops.

Approaches to Statistical and Linguistic Analysis

There are many tools available that do not verify the AI’s output against the original source but verify the quality of the actual language used, as well as its usefulness. For example, they can rate a text for readability, cohesion, and closeness to the original style. They are also used to determine how often a summary produced by a given model must be manually corrected or even rewritten.

Consistency in AI Summaries

Consistency refers to reflecting of all factual details of the original text in an AI-generated summary as well as presenting them in a uniform way. Coherence means making sure that the summary will have a logical sequence of points and will be easy to read. Various techniques on how to achieve coherence and consistency include training AI models to adapt to different styles and writing methods and implementing advanced natural language processing methods to replicate certain techniques associated with a certain style. Maintaining coherence and consistency is essential for generating summaries as it allows making sure that the outcome will accurately mirror the text’s original sequence and tone.

AI-generated summaries

Ways to ensure consistency

Various training techniques can be used to make sure that generation of a summary will be consistent with the original style. AI models need to be trained on diverse datasets so that they can generate summaries in different writing styles while adapting to gradually identified regularities. If, for instance, the source material describes a series of medical journal articles, the AI will most likely generate a summary in a serious and specific tone. In this case, the AI will have to learn to generate summaries using accurate and formal medical terminology. Advanced natural language processing techniques will be required to be able to detect the tone of the passage and produce summaries in the same tone. Another method of achieving this is employing proper NLP models. For example, an NLP model that focuses on semantics will be useful for detecting and replicating certain expressions and methods used in the source text.

Ways to ensure coherence

As generating summaries requires condensation an original sequence of points and facts into a shorter version, things get progressively more difficult. Thus, ensuring coherence is particularly challenging for AI-generated summaries. Even though cohesion can be achieved by using sophisticated algorithms, making sure that logical points are at the beginning of the summary and less logical are at the end is crucial and harder to achieve. AI needs to be trained to identify and assign the most important points as the first ones. Moreover, summarizing into a coherent format also includes replicating the text’s original structure. Most sources will identify certain five points that need to be discussed, such as the main point of the passage, hypothesis, method, results, and discussion . While the AI would not be able to generate summaries that are too big, it needs to follow the same format to properly reflect the text. Ways to ensure coherence are referencing the structure of the original source and making sure that logical points are at the beginning of the summary. Finally, continuous learning should be implemented as different sources may require different points to be identified.

The efficiency of AI summary

Being designed with sophisticated natural language processing techniques, AI algorithms adequately scanning their inputs can also identify the most recurring and unusual themes, making sure that the summary reflects the most important aspect and that the essence of the original text remains intact . However, the efficiency may drop when the AI is facing ambiguous language, negation, sarcasm, or highly nuanced topics – then the success of AI depends on the number of examples in its training corpus and the specificity of context, up to the particular topic the AI is based on. Efficiency is not just a buzzword for AI-generated summaries. AI-generated summaries can be delivered within a few seconds, while human specialists, depending on the complexity of the document, may need several minutes or hours to summarize an extensive text. Moreover, this is not achieved at the expense of quality – the medical article summarization AI analyzed by Feng Zhao would deliver a reduction in reading time for professionals by nearly 70% while retaining the same level of important information .

AI-induced efficiency comes from its sheer ability to read and understand language on a scale that is unreachable for humans. The training of the summarization AI deployed by Feng Zhao, or any similar AI tool, had to be based on dozens of thousands to millions of documents. Hence, while the ability to deliver a summary in seconds is not to be underestimated, the ability to precisely define its length or the most plausible focus area is just another way in which AI use proves to be quite efficient. Nevertheless, AI, like all technologies, should be utilized in a balanced and measured way; while AI thrives on clear, simple language, it is not well-equipped for ambiguity or poorly structured information.

Table of Contents

Fast AI Transcription

Transcription conversation to text & and get real-time insights